Let . The space of weight- cusp forms has dimension . The Hecke algebra is a free -module of rank . Its discriminant is The -adic valuation signals that is not a maximal order. The purpose of this paper is to give a complete description of the singular locus.
Over , the algebra splits as a product of fields corresponding to the Galois orbits of newforms. Among the -dimensional space, there is a unique non-semisimple -adic local factor of rank , involving two newform branches whose Hecke eigenvalues are congruent modulo . We identify these branches, give the exact algebra presentation, and develop the full local theory: ideals, modules, and representations.
The number is the largest Heegner discriminant: has class number one. The seven Heegner discriminants define Hecke operators on . Their behaviour on the singular factor is a motivating example throughout, though our results are purely local and do not depend on the Heegner property.
Our main contributions are:
An explicit presentation of the singular order (Theorem [thm:presentation]).
The identification of the glued newform pair as (rational) and one -factor of the degree- orbit, with the Atkin–Lehner eigenvalue characterising the node (Theorem [thm:branches]).
A complete ideal classification with closed-form local zeta function (Theorem [thm:ideals]).
The residue representation theory: two simples, one unique non-split self-extension (Theorem [thm:residue]).
A classification of all torsion-free (Cohen–Macaulay) modules: three indecomposables (Theorem [thm:CM]).
The singularity category with -periodic suspension, Grothendieck group , and explicit stable Ext algebra (Theorem [thm:singcat]).
Let . The operator acts on the -dimensional space and its characteristic polynomial factors over into irreducible pieces corresponding to Galois orbits of newforms. We write for the rational eigenform (the unique elliptic curve of conductor ), for a degree- orbit, for a degree- eigenform with -eigenvalue , and the remaining dimensions for other orbits.
There exists a unique non-semisimple local factor of of rank over , with $$\Osing \;\cong\; \mathbf{Z}_3\, e_7 \;\oplus\; \mathbf{Z}_3\, e_{\mathrm{pair}} \;\oplus\; \mathbf{Z}_3\, n$$ as a -module, with multiplication Equivalently, $$\Osing \;\cong\; \mathbf{Z}_3 \times \mathbf{Z}_3[\eta]/(\eta^2 - 3\eta),$$ where the first factor corresponds to the split branch and the pair factor $$\Rpair \;=\; \mathbf{Z}_3[\eta]/(\eta^2 - 3\eta)$$ carries the glued branches and .
Proof. Computed by lifting the mod- idempotent from and verifying the relations modulo for (i.e., modulo ). The suborder generated by has index in the full Hecke order, which is prime to , so it determines the same -adic local factor. ◻
The relation encodes the full node. Factoring: , so has eigenvalues and in the normalisation . Modulo , both eigenvalues are zero: this is the collision. Over , they separate.
The pair factor admits the congruence description $$\Rpair \;\cong\; \{(a,b) \in \mathbf{Z}_3 \times \mathbf{Z}_3 : a \equiv b \pmod{3}\},$$ via . The normalisation is , the conductor is $\mathfrak{f} = 3\mathbf{Z}_3 \times 3\mathbf{Z}_3 = \m$, and the normalisation defect $\widetilde{R}/\Rpair$ has -length .
Proof. The map , is an injective ring homomorphism whose image is exactly the pairs congruent modulo . The conductor computation is direct. ◻
The full singular order is $$\Osing \;\cong\; \{(x_7, x_1, x_5) \in \mathbf{Z}_3^3 : x_1 \equiv x_5 \pmod{3}\},$$ where is the -coordinate and are the - and -coordinates.
The glued pair consists of:
: the rational newform (the elliptic curve of conductor ), with Atkin–Lehner eigenvalue .
: one -factor of the degree- Galois orbit, also with .
The split branch is , with . Modulo , the Hecke eigenvalues of and are identical on all operators. Modulo , they separate: and .
Proof. Computed from the -expansions of all newforms of level , reduced modulo successive powers of . ◻
The Atkin–Lehner involution separates the node () from the split branch (). The Heegner operators on the syndrome take the values shown in Table 1.
| — | |||
The Jacobson radical of $\Osing$ is and its powers are In particular:
$\Osing / J \cong \mathbf{F}_3 \times \mathbf{F}_3$ is two-dimensional semisimple.
$J / 3\Osing$ is one-dimensional: the nilpotent shadow.
$\Osing / 3\Osing \cong \mathbf{F}_3 \times \mathbf{F}_3[\varepsilon]/(\varepsilon^2)$ is three-dimensional.
for all .
The associated graded ring of $\Rpair$ with respect to $\m = (3, \eta)$ is $$\gr_\m(\Rpair) \;\cong\; \mathbf{F}_3[a, g]/(g^2 - ag) \;=\; \mathbf{F}_3[a,g]/(g(g-a)).$$ This is the coordinate ring of two lines crossing at the origin in the affine plane over .
Proof. In $\Rpair$, write for the image of and for the image of in $\m/\m^2$. Then gives , i.e., . ◻
The spectrum $\Spec(\Rpair)$ is a split nodal curve over : two smooth branches meeting transversally at the closed point. This is the geometric content of .
The residue algebra $\Osing / 3\Osing$ is with . Writing , , , the syndrome relations are and the Heegner operators descend as
The canonical collision is a first-order phenomenon: these operators already differ modulo . The algebra forces the collision, since both must map to the same element of the three-dimensional residue ring.
Let $R_k = \Rpair / 3^k \Rpair$ for .
Each graded piece $\m^r / \m^{r+1} \cong \mathbf{F}_3^2$ for all .
Between $\m^{r+1}$ and $\m^r$ in there are exactly four intermediate ideals, indexed by , with generators in the congruence model.
The total number of ideals of is .
For the full singular order, every ideal of $\Osing / 3^k \Osing$ splits uniquely as , giving ideals in total.
The Solomon zeta functions are $$\zeta_{\Rpair}(s) = \frac{1 + x + 3x^2}{1 - x^2}, \qquad \zeta_{\Osing}(s) = \frac{1 + x + 3x^2}{(1-x)(1-x^2)}, \quad x = 3^{-s}.$$
The residue algebra has exactly two simple modules:
: the character , .
: the character , .
The regular module decomposes as $$A_{\mathrm{reg}} \;\cong\; \chi_{V7} \;\oplus\; \Ppair,$$ where $\Ppair$ is the unique non-split self-extension of : $$0 \to \chi_{\mathrm{pair}} \to \Ppair \to \chi_{\mathrm{pair}} \to 0.$$ The extension table is $$\Ext^1(\chi_{\mathrm{pair}}, \chi_{\mathrm{pair}}) \cong \mathbf{F}_3, \qquad \Ext^1(\chi_{V7}, -) = \Ext^1(-, \chi_{V7}) = 0.$$ In particular, the branch admits no residue-level extension to or from the glued block.
The category of torsion-free (Cohen–Macaulay) modules over $\Rpair$ has finite representation type. The indecomposable objects are exactly:
$B_0 = \Rpair / (\eta) \cong \mathbf{Z}_3$, with acting as (branch ).
$B_3 = \Rpair / (\eta - 3) \cong \mathbf{Z}_3$, with acting as (branch ).
$\Rpair$ itself (the node), of -rank .
Every torsion-free $\Rpair$-module is isomorphic to $$B_0^u \;\oplus\; \Rpair^c \;\oplus\; B_3^v$$ for unique .
Proof. A torsion-free $\Rpair$-module of rank over the normalisation determines a gluing subspace given by the image of $M / \m M$ in . Every such subspace decomposes uniquely as where is a left kernel, is a right kernel, and is the diagonal (the paired coordinates glued at residue level). This forces $$M \;\cong\; B_0^{|K_0|} \;\oplus\; \Rpair^c \;\oplus\; B_3^{|K_3|}.$$ For rank , the only indecomposable gluing space is the diagonal , giving $\Rpair$. All other rank- gluings split as . The argument extends to arbitrary rank by the same diagonal decomposition. ◻
The three indecomposables have a natural interpretation: and are the two branches of the node, and $\Rpair$ is the node itself — the unique indecomposable that “sees” both branches simultaneously. The category is of finite type precisely because $\Rpair$ is a Bass order (a Gorenstein order in a commutative semisimple algebra of dimension ).
The two branch modules are linked by the node:
There are two fundamental short exact sequences of $\Rpair$-modules: $$\begin{aligned} \label{eq:ses1} 0 \to B_3 \xrightarrow{\;\iota_3\;} \Rpair \xrightarrow{\;\pi_0\;} B_0 \to 0, \\ \label{eq:ses2} 0 \to B_0 \xrightarrow{\;\iota_0\;} \Rpair \xrightarrow{\;\pi_3\;} B_3 \to 0, \end{aligned}$$ where in [eq:ses1], maps and is projection modulo ; in [eq:ses2], maps and is projection modulo .
Proof. Direct verification using . ◻
In the singularity category $D_{\mathrm{sg}}(\Rpair) = \underline{\CM}(\Rpair)$, the free module $\Rpair$ becomes zero. What remains is the minimal non-trivial structure.
The singularity category $D_{\mathrm{sg}}(\Rpair)$ has exactly two indecomposable objects, and , with the suspension functor acting as The Auslander–Reiten quiver is with the AR translation swapping the two vertices. The Grothendieck group is $$K_0(D_{\mathrm{sg}}(\Rpair)) \;\cong\; \mathbf{Z}/2\mathbf{Z}.$$
Proof. The suspension is computed from the exact sequence [eq:ses1]: the syzygy of is . Similarly, from [eq:ses2]. Thus and the category is -periodic. Since $[B_0] + [B_3] = [\Rpair] = 0$ in and , we get generated by . ◻
The stable Ext algebra of $D_{\mathrm{sg}}(\Rpair)$ is generated by:
two odd generators $x \in \underline{\Ext}^1(B_0, B_3)$ and $y \in \underline{\Ext}^1(B_3, B_0)$, corresponding to the extension classes of [eq:ses1] and [eq:ses2];
one even periodicity class of degree , with and .
This is the path algebra of the double arrow modulo the relation that the two compositions are the respective identity multiples.
The -periodicity is intrinsic to the node: it is the homological manifestation of the two branches exchanging roles under syzygies. After modding out the smooth directions (both the free module $\Rpair$ and the split branch), the Hecke singularity reduces to a single bit of information: , the minimal non-trivial decategorification.
Using the identification , , , the Heegner operators act on $\Osing$ as the following elements of $\mathbf{Z}_3 \times \Rpair$:
| Operator | Syndrome (mod ) | Exact form in $\Osing$ |
|---|---|---|
| , split mod | ||
| , split mod | ||
The operator is the local generator of the nilpotent direction: it maps to (up to sign and unit) in the pair factor. The collision is forced by the residue algebra and splits at the first -adic thickening. The operator acts as on both branches of the node, consistent with the Atkin–Lehner eigenvalue .
A scan of levels shows that levels and (the other large Heegner class-number-one discriminants) have trivial mod- syndrome quotient: over . Level is the first class-number-one level with a genuine three-dimensional syndrome quotient. The singular node described in this paper is therefore specific to level within the class-number-one family, though similar nodal structures can occur at other levels and primes.
The singular -adic Hecke factor at level is completely described by one relation: . From this single quadratic identity over , we derived:
the congruence-order model ;
the nodal geometry with tangent cone ;
the Jacobson filtration of constant width ;
the syndrome algebra as exact mod- shadow;
the -bouquet of ideals at each depth;
the local zeta function ;
the residue Ext table with $\Ext^1(\chi_{\mathrm{pair}}, \chi_{\mathrm{pair}}) \cong \mathbf{F}_3$ as the unique non-semisimple direction;
the three CM indecomposables , $\Rpair$, constituting the full module category;
the singularity category $D_{\mathrm{sg}}(\Rpair)$ with two objects, -periodic suspension, and ;
the explicit Heegner operator images confirming the collision and as local generator.
The object is a two-state semisimple skeleton plus one nilpotent shadow, giving a three-state residue core with infinite -adic refinement of constant width . In the singularity category, even this reduces further: one bit, two branches, period .
Computational verification. All results were verified in SageMath at precision using the full integral Hecke algebra at level . The explicit data are recorded in Appendix 12.
We record the exact computational inputs underlying the main theorems.
Over , the characteristic polynomial of on the integral modular-symbols space factors as The three factors correspond to the Galois orbits (degree ), (degree ), and (degree ), with .
Modulo : The -primary component is , of dimension .
In the adapted basis of , the seven Heegner operators act as the following matrices over : One verifies directly that , that , , and .
Expressing the Heegner operators in the basis of and lifting from to :
The collision is visible in the first column. The two operators separate modulo : the -coefficients are and respectively. This separation is the -adic manifestation of the nilpotent direction in the pair factor .
On the -dimensional algebra : In particular, for all , confirming that the nilpotent direction lies in the radical of the trace form (rank ).
99
B. Mazur, Modular curves and the Eisenstein ideal, Publ. Math. IHES 47 (1977), 33–186.
K. Ribet and W. Stein, Lectures on modular forms and Hecke operators, https://wstein.org/books/ribet-stein/.
Y. A. Drozd and V. V. Kirichenko, Finite dimensional algebras, Springer, 1994.
G.-M. Greuel and H. Knörrer, Einfache Kurvensingularitäten und torsionsfreie Moduln, Math. Ann. 270 (1985), 417–425.
H. Bass, On the ubiquity of Gorenstein rings, Math. Z. 82 (1963), 8–28.
F. Calegari and D. Geraghty, Modularity lifting beyond the Taylor–Wiles method, Invent. Math. 211 (2018), 297–433.
R.-O. Buchweitz, Maximal Cohen–Macaulay modules and Tate cohomology over Gorenstein rings, unpublished manuscript (1986), published posthumously, Math. Surveys Monogr. 262, AMS, 2021.